Comments : IF he really loved me.

  • 16 years ago

    by Alex

    It's really good

  • 16 years ago

    by tiffany

    I love this poem.

  • 16 years ago

    by Amber

    Ok that's good.
    But In my opinion I think It'd be a bit better if like it was maybe a little longer and more emotions poured out of it. Maybe a bit of imagery too would make it also better.

  • I really liked this one...
    And that's true what you said...

  • 16 years ago

    by XxFailedxForgottonxX

    Really Great Poem

  • 16 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    This is pretty good, really cliche but I have some suggesstions:

    "If he really loved me he'd tell me he's sorry.
    If he really loved me he'd come back to me.
    If he really loved me he'd tell me he loves me."

    ^Okay, first off the repetition....Poems that keep repeating like yours does "If he really loved me he'd....." doesn't keep the reader interested and doesn't capture their attention.
    Maybe try something like this to not repeat so much:

    "Still wishing that he'd profess his love for me,"

    Or just write different and unique lines that aren't the same cliche things in love poems.

    You can still repeat that one line, "if he really loved me...." but not so much that it gets boring. Experiment with words, try different things, put more emotions into it and it will be a lot better. Keep writing!

    If he really loved me he'd show his love.
    If he really loved me he wouldn't lie to me.
    If he really loved me he wouldn't hurt me.
    but these ifs will never come true because he's not sorry and he doesn't love me. If only he know how much I loved him. But now he'll never know.

  • 16 years ago

    by CanUKissAwayMyPain

    I really love this poem. awesome job =)

  • 16 years ago

    by kerrigan

    It is actually not that bad 3/5 keep it up

  • 16 years ago

    by Cristian Teo Regalado

    Its sad when people have someone so good in front of them and they dont realize it and never will sorry this happened to u it happened to me to many times lol...5/5

  • 16 years ago

    by halie

    Awwww,
    its sad :(
    but rlly good
    i felt the same way about my ex,
    tht is now my boyfriend again
    but things will work out in the end,
    trust meh :)
    5/5
    great job

    -halie

  • 16 years ago

    by confused

    I liked it. it was real and i understand im
    in the same thing right now wit a guy that hasn't showed me he loves me in a long time

  • 16 years ago

    by Becca

    This was really good in that I can completely relate. I'm in that situation right now. I voted 4/5 because I think it could have flowed better. Great job though.

  • Thats a good poem maybe if u add more rhyming no matter the repition it would be better its a good poem but try rhyming ok keep up the good work though

  • 16 years ago

    by Lilly Tagloff

    Oh snap.
    my bf just broke up with me and i can relate to this so much.
    it is TOTALLY true. exactly how i feel.
    nice job. 5/5

  • 16 years ago

    by BlueEyedMystery

    To be honest..

    I didn't really like this. It didn't have any emotion at all in it, and the repetition almost drove me insane. ><

    It just seemed like you stated you feelings.. no poetic tone or anything. I've heard this all before and it just really doesn't interest me.

    Try metaphors, similes, imagery just anything to make the poem unique and special. Open you heart and let the words flow from your soul. Write from you heart and you'll feel the emotion when you read the poem. I know you can do it if you really try.

    Sorry if this was harsh; I'm really not a mean person. ><

    Keep writing; never give up!

    .||CAYYCE||.

  • 16 years ago

    by Rachel RTVW

    Too much repetition. If, he me......It lacks flow and is not creative. The imagery is non-existent. Not front page material and definetly not what I would expect to win the weekly contest.

  • 16 years ago

    by Spoken Silence

    I agree, this poem seemed to lack emotion. More of a thought that you put together, If you added more emotion in to this, and added rhymes or anything else to seperate the repetition this would have been good. This wasn't a weekly competition material either, I know you could do better, keep writing and put more of a flow in to your work.

  • 16 years ago

    by marleine

    Hi Megan, your poem is so nice, i feel it comes out from so deep inside you! it seems like a true experience! so nice

  • 16 years ago

    by Goodbye

    I don't know how I would define what is a "poem" but honestly for me...This is not really a poem. It seems like someone is repeating sentences to herself.

    This poem is little bit lack of imagination.

    I don't mean to insult you but this is my honest opinion.

  • U so deserved your win. Great Poem