Just to get some things out of the way...
Couple of typos:
'Finially' -- Finally
"My stomach would get major butterflies just 'THEY' way..." -- the
Okay then...
I really liked the emotion and meaning behind the poem just at the end it was a little confusing as to which "it's about time" is referring to. Are you referring to the fact that you are finally over this Tyler person or is it the fact that this person has finally realised you were there and had these feelings..??
However, the poem itself was great, lacked flow but you're still young, and you will learn heaps off this site. (: