Comments : Hypothetical Garden

  • 13 years ago

    by nouriguess

    Nana, you have no idea how well-written this was, being surrounded by disappointment, unable to realize where to end up, and the saddest part that stood out to me was the one about following a naught and falling in love with a zero...oh gosh! how I felt ...clueless! didn't even know what to feel! So all of this happiness was just a mirage!? say it not! I'm so sorry if this is real and claps for you if it's just from imagination. It would be really warming if you cry on my shoulder now. <3

    I told you many times...leave this room. It ain't necessary to have someone by your side, you can do it on your own/ + I am here! ;) I know it doesn't matter but when you want to find someone to care for you, you will...because you are a great person, Nana. And I'm not saying this just to get my comment praised...you know this, don't you? since our friendship is no more behind the screen.

    This was so creative..dear. So sad, but creative. I Love you.

  • 13 years ago

    by Decayed

    First, the title is stunning: Hypothetical Garden?

    ^ This can be real something, something great. You're just visualizing a garden..!! It provokes me.

    It's sad that I raise my voice
    in a room raised by four
    walls of mirage, and perhaps
    surrounded by meaningless clutter.
    That only fools, understand the
    depth of the unawareness in my words

    ^ I can hear the tone here. Speaking so LOUDLY.. with no boundaries. Shrieking in the face of nothingness! Amazing opening..

    to arrive from nothing, to follow naught
    then fall in love with a zero,
    so sad to end up being a mad storm
    or perhaps not to end up at all..

    ^ the last two lines has just something so wise for me.. and falling in love with a zero? That really had me pondering.

    It's not sad, it's actually terrible to
    raise my voice in such a cold room
    raised over debris, with a ceiling
    equipped with disappointment ,
    a window that views on hills of discontent

    ^ Why do you insist in making me sad? and discontented?
    But at any level, if poetry, like acting, is just transforming atmospheres/emotions to the reader/viewer. Then you're a real poetess.. You make'em feel and live with the poem.

    that opens on trees gathered
    by a fog of lost answers, faces,
    seats, and empty cups pushed by
    frigid winds,
    a chain of shuddering belongings
    that absolutely belong to none!

    ^ Omg.. my favorite stanza. So hypothetical, indeed.. but so stormy.. and cold. I love those materialistic objects, combined with noon-materialistic (answers) you have used. They just give life to the poem and embark on provoking imagination. LOVE it.

    Visions filled with ice...
    such a cold evening, this one.
    Living in a hypothetical garden
    of love and happiness.
    So excuse me, and my sad gibberish
    I might just sleep for a real while now.

    ^ GIBBERISH is so smooth though it sounds rough. It really helps your idea. It came in the right place, supporting the hypothetical thoughts.

    And the end? As if so tired of what's been said and imagined.. and you just need some rest, for a fresh new start and for those thoughts of happiness and sadness to go...!!

    Nana. I'm so impressed right now.

    A nomination is a must, for this one.

    HIGH HIGH HIGH Five :)

  • 13 years ago

    by PinkyPrincess

    Awww... Nana, as always, your poems really touch me! I loved the title - it immediately caught my eye. I liked the sadness and rawness of this poem... I like the idea of screaming alone, within four walls.. and feeling like 'nothing' ... I think the emotions you expressed are very relatable. I like that this is a cold, sad room, and how you describe it as gibberish at the end.. as the reader, I felt like this was true, and this person is truly lost and by the end of this poem, is speaking nonsense or going crazy from the hurt and decided to sleep it off... and the pattern continues... That's the way I interpreted it anyway!!

    Well done sweetie! Another amazing poem by the lovely Ms Sunshine <3

  • 13 years ago

    by Boy

    Nana this poem is beyond my thoughts and very difficult for me to understand.. because i want to be a honest with you.. so be honest i really did not understand this poem meaning and idea. as i told you this is beyond my thoughts and something that is not in my perception..

    it would be definitely a good piece even i didn't understand.. that's why i cannot say something about this poem. i wish i have such heart and thinking to understand it.. and i would elaborate it like always i elaborate your poems in my own words... very difficult this time..

    hope you wrote and found what you wanted to achieve by writing this poem...

    take care
    your friend
    Alone

  • 12 years ago

    by Sherry Lynn

    Nana,

    I have been wanting to comment on this for several days, but life has prevented me from being able to do so.

    I love this piece and how it screams out to the reader. I can feel your loneliness, heartache, and sadness.

    This piece is absolutely amazing and definitely deserves to be nominated.

    The wording is true art and opens up all the raw emotions for the reader. I felt as though I was sitting there watching you and not just reading a few lines.

    Thank you for sharing this.

  • 12 years ago

    by Michael D Nalley

    This imagery reminds me of a longing to return to the garden of paradise

    great free flow