Comments : Flightless birds[Chained haiku]

  • 12 years ago

    by Alanis

    This poem had a meaning that stuck out tramendisly! well done!

  • 12 years ago

    by average thoughts

    I always wanted to write a poem on child labor bt nvr cum up wid sumthing to show d pain they go thru, bt this piece u wrote for them ..seriously, u tuk time bt u did d justice wid d title..thanks

  • 12 years ago

    by Khalid M Darwish

    Really brilliant!
    I guess that "idreas" gives 3 syllables (not 2)
    But even though I really loved the topic you're penning this poem about and how it is important to talk about as well as your choice of making it as chained haiku style. Well done

  • 12 years ago

    by Jenna Bella Oldridge

    A lovely write but it was also very sad and emotional. Even though the poem wasn't very long I felt it said alot and it really stood out to me.

    5/5

  • 12 years ago

    by LostWords

    Even better the second time I've read it! You always have such a deep meaning to your writings.

  • 12 years ago

    by Chelsey

    Oh my gosh Amreen, really interesting topic. I love this chained haiku, very nice creativity, because anyone can write a chained haiku, but the creativity lies in the fact that you wrote it about nature which is what a haiku is, but the nature you chose (young birds) was a metaphor for child labor. I just found that really interesting. Seriously, well done! Excellent wording!

  • 12 years ago

    by Darren

    Amreen

    I have recorded your review on the following link

    http://vocaroo.com/i/s0PYU0DOVeTd

    hope you like it.

  • 12 years ago

    by Hannah Lizette

    Who knew that writing about something so heartbreaking could turn out beautiful like this? Seriously, I'm amazed by this piece. I adore the metaphor of the young birds for child labor.

    First stanza: Minds of children start to spread their wings for the first time and truly learn about all the great possibilities in life.

    Second: I love paint the sky with wisdom and chirp new ideas...seriously great word choices. As the young children start to follow their dreams, figure out who they truly are... they are the new generation, so they are our future.

    Third: A twist of fate. Their dreams come crashing down and they are exposed to some of the cruelest things in life. I like how you incorporated the 'wind' in here to tie along with the birds.

    Fourth: Young children being slaves, it just truly breaks my heart. I can't bare to even think about it.

    Fifth: The children have no life but to work... no happiness, nothing... They live to please them... pretty much have them shackled down and cut their wings off... so they are flightless.

    Amazing write... nominating! :D

  • 12 years ago

    by LittleMermaid

    Excellent poem Amreen..
    few words have spoken great n deep meanings!
    *_*

  • 12 years ago

    by The Queen of Spades

    I really, really enjoyed this piece! Haiku is one of my favorite forms of poetry and you've definitely mastered the art in this piece. The subject is provocative and deep, which makes it all the better. Beautiful!

  • 12 years ago

    by PETER EDWARDS

    A brilliant piece. Words fail me.
    This is a beautiful poem so full of realism.
    In this harsh and unloving world we live in, these words bring a shaft of welcome light into the corners of mankinds evil deeds..
    Thank you for sharing this poem with us.

  • 12 years ago

    by Ingrid

    Brilliant sweetheart!

    5/5 Ingrid

  • 12 years ago

    by Lostlove1

    Awesome haikuing Amreen. Keep it up. You are really good at this form! Such a sad message inside this powerful piece. Be proud of this poem Amreen.

    5/5

    Lostlove~

  • 12 years ago

    by East Poetry

    I love everything about this poem, I especially like the correlation as you tie your topic to the flight
    of the free bird.

    My only critique is that these young spirits definitely add new ideas to the world. but to use the word "wisdom" kind of through me off a bit.
    to me wisdom is a thing that only comes with age and this poem is all about children. You might consider changing that word.

    loved it though!!

    5/5

  • I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PIECE.

    The message.
    The message is a powerful one and one that should definitely be heard. Things like this are still occurring and it's really not fair on children. All children have the right to a safe and happy childhood, but sadly, this is not what every child gets. So great message to get out there.

    The idea.
    I love this idea. Not only the message, but the idea of using the birds to show this message it's a really clever way because many represent birds as either free or caged. I like the idea that these "birds" are flightless, their wings are clipped, so freedom is not achievable. They can run, but it won't help, because this is what they MUST do often to support their families. I really love the bird theme << have I mentioned that?! lol. Well done.

    The form.
    I personally find Haikus difficult to write because of the lack of space with the syllables. Its very restricted. So I especially love your talent for being able to write several perfectly joined haikus. Superb!

    Word choice/arrangement.
    Incredible word choice. This also links with the bird theme, and I really like that. But not only your word choice, the way you have arranged the words and the poem as a whole is incredible. I love the innocence and hope feeling of the first couple of haikus only for the mood to turn dark - it's incredibly arranged.

    The emotion.
    Yes, the emotion is evident throughout the whole piece. Very strong indeed, and I think close to your heart..? As I said above, the first couple of stanzas seem to express such feelings of innocence, hope and joy (i.e. what a childhood should be like) but then things turn sorrowful and horrible which truly makes the message that much more impactful.

    The imagery.
    The use of the birds instantly gives incredible imagery. But not only that it makes the reader think of other things similar to those that are trapping the birds which give rise to thoughts of child exploitation as you have intended. Beautiful work.

    Overall;
    This piece is brilliant. I am so glad you have written this and shared it with the world. I really hope people listen to this and this can be resolved as soon as possible. No child should suffer such ways of life.

    Excellent. 5/5

  • 12 years ago

    by Xanthe

    This is lovely. I like the title because it easily captures the reader's attention. Birds are usually associated with freedom since they can fly, but to think that they are 'flightless' contradicts that.
    Haiku/s oftentimes simply show a still moment; an image; juxtaposes images and such. But this told a story, and it is a very good eye-opener.

  • 12 years ago

    by Decayed

    I loved your topic, Amreen. And since you restricted yourself in one form, you'll get more applause. Greatly expressed.

  • 12 years ago

    by TSI25

    Very very morbid, and something which definitely deserves more attention in the US. topic wise i encourage you to continue writing poems like this one, and over all it was very beautifully written. i liked that each of the stanzas was pretty much a standalone haiku, but given nuance and context from the ones before and after. a very enjoyable read.

  • 12 years ago

    by Lune de ma vie

    Love the metaphor of the kids being birds and the loss of the feathers. This is really cool, a great metaphorical poem with a deep passionate message that you care about.

  • 12 years ago

    by Formidable Muse

    This is so deep and emotional. Such a beautiful write.
    I did find some minor errors with the 5,7,5 count, but the poem over all was extremely powerful.
    5/5 from me.