Comments : Postcard

  • 11 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    Mel, the images and emotion in this piece filled me with a longing to understand this pain as well as the burdens that are still being carried on....

    The first scene you described shows this is a poor part of the city, where there is unmarked crime and poverty, and you are lost here, possibly thinking of home and how you have gotten here. That first line especially made me think your group is vagabonds, constantly finding little, simple things for shelter.

    The sadness broke my heart , like you have no space to call your own, you don't go outside into the real daylight and live...and whether this is an apartment or shelter, there are many others with you who don't have opportunities at the moment. I can tell you are broken and filled with hopelessness...I also got the feeling you are someone who has a caring heart but a lot of depth in it, so when you try to find love again it's hard, because you never were held by that fierce, pure love of who I assumed would be your father.

    I literally got shivers all over. I'm a firm believer in the way you were raised can play a huge importance in how you grow into your own shoes. I know children go on to shape/form their own opinions and beliefs which they should, but parents teach them things that can't be necessarily taught in words or textbooks...so I think when a child is absent from affection, he/she grows without it and searches for their own meaning & faith... maybe they don't think it exists for them, you know?

    Such a chilling piece. I aspire to write with your honesty and raw emotion, whatever the topic may be I admire you because you show the hard steps of a person's story, not just the beautiful moments, but the ones it's tough to imagine. These are the kinds of poems that can make a person turn around, change their mind about ignoring certain things in life.... although I'm probably looking too much into this, there's an open vulnerability in this piece that shows and displays people's wounds. We all have them and we have to acknowledge them sometimes, that just because we may have control in our lives doesn't mean we won't feel abandoned or living without security in jobs, moneys, etc.

    There is so much surreal aching in this piece. It seriously puts me in this character's (woman right?) shoes and made me think a thousand things. I would never think her thoughts would I? Because I've never been in her situation and probably the first thing I would feel is pity, not understanding. Not trying to know her life.

    Incredible Mel, I'm just....I could go on and on and still not feel I'm doing it justice as to what my thoughts are reading after because this is one poem that reaches the reader's soul. Sorry about all my rambling, hope it wasn't too much, just wanted you to know everything running through my head in response to reading!

    Glad you posted this and happy to see a new poem, hope you are doing well......Nominating Monday :]

  • 11 years ago

    by Britt

    So, I'll be honest. I've been putting off commenting on this poem because I love it so much. Contrary, I know... but I can't decide what to say.

    Like I told you before, the way you described vitamin D seriously just tickles my fancy, lol. I LOVE that and thought it was really interesting. You take daily objects and turn them into such creative little masterpieces (the artist in you of course), but also can mask it in a way that people probably wouldn't know, unless they know you and whats going on in your world, lol.

    I'm really intrigued by the first part of your poem, and am a little flustered I can't figure it out. To me it's definitely vampire-like... but the spine is the sharp edge and not the crucifix. I noticed that immediately, so I'm really interested in it.

    "I can't find my ancestors in my skin tone anymore, so
    I swallow these tiny suns hoping my fingers won't ache
    at night. "

    THIS. The lack of vitamin D, no sunshine for your skin so you're missing that olive tone of your family. I really like the way you wrote this. They're still there, but you aren't physically connected by looks. You're someone else today.

    I really love how you portray the city... that it's broken and we need help.. the end where it says it's fallen and God isn't here anymore, it's like you're saying we NEED Him here, which obviously we do. I also really like how you go to childhood. Sometimes when people are down and need to escape they think about a happy past.. but here you have sad memories as well.. so you reflect. You learn, which is a part of becoming and adult and able to forgive people, even though it's hard. It's not making excuses but understanding the situation in a different light. People love you the way they know how, and if they weren't taught to love in a good, healthy and respectful way, how will they ever know? It's a nature versus nurture thing, which I think really is what you're entire poem feels about. The city is nature (not spring-time frolic-y nature, but environment) and that's proof that there is a broken, fallen world out there. But you received nurturing from your mother so you didn't learn to love the way he did.

    This is really just so beautiful. I can't help but read this poem over and over and over again. Going into my favorites.

    Oh, and the title. I really like that, how you're sending someone a postcard of the city - the pain, the picture of brokenness. Beautiful (even though it's incredibly depressing, haha!).

  • 11 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    Congrats on your win Mel!!! In every line you express such a raw tone of sadness and in each description/metaphor you show the reader this hopelessness of this woman, who is in need of love. It's just beautiful and I know I'll keep this in my favorites.

    Incredibly well-deserved!

  • 11 years ago

    by Yakari Gabriel

    I love this
    I owe you a big comment

    the ending was my favorite.

    I love your poetry
    I love your soul
    I love you.

    <3
    most well deserved win ever.

  • 11 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    [Judging comment from week of 7/08/13]:

    There is such tangible pain expressed in this poem and the very vulnerable opening image of living in poverty and feeling broken just reaches out to me. I love how you described almost feeling betrayed by the city, no longer free but crowded in this apartment and unable to truly have happiness at your fingertips. I envision this woman struggling to regain her strength yet everything in her surrounding weighs her down.....the ending was extremely depressing. These lines hit me emotionally: "I realize my childhood's recollection of intimacy/and realize he was never loved so/he couldn't love us right." I immediately thought of the father. I know fathers are those models for girls and if they don't have that loving relationship and be that support, a girl can be lost when she is growing up.

    Also, that last line mentioning God was like a silent plea. So much emotion and hopelessness. Like your cry to God is in vain because you know he wouldn't want to fix a broken soul. But he is everywhere, we don't have to be perfect to have him near and I think that's hard to realize. Such a deep journey through this woman's most inner thoughts.
    Incredibly moving! My heart aches reading each stanza.

  • 11 years ago

    by Jenni Marie

    Judging comment:

    "I have to admit, when I saw that Mel had a new poem I was incredibly excited to see it, and it didn't fail to disappoint. This is beautiful. Haunting, melancholic, but beautiful. She pulls of this emotion simultaneously as only she can do.

    This is one of those poems that even though it is so sad and heart breaking I can't help but keep coming back to it and repeatedly reading it over and over. The whole poem oozes with unadulterated emotion and I can't help but sit back in awe at the entire piece.

    "I've been dodging charity on the sidewalk,
    too frightened of the confession in my voice. I
    wonder if they could tell I haven't eaten lately? and
    I'm in debt for an education so it's rare I sleep at night. "

    I adore this particular part. To me it seems like broken thoughts, harried and rushed and yet some that just absolutely have to be shared. Because of the fragmented thoughts it adds to the sense of urgency behind the words.

    "and realize he was never loved so
    he couldn't love us right. "

    My other favourite part. Isn't this always the case? If someone isn't taught to love properly and honestly then of course they love others the way they themselves were loved, even if it's in such a negative way. And this is incredibly sad.

    The last line, just wow. Such a brutal ending to such a jerking poem and of course one that ties it together perfectly. I shows that all hope is lost, that this city Mel describes (and perhaps the people, too?) are lost within themselves, broken and devoid of hope.

    That maybe God has given up because they have given up on themselves and Him also.

    I simply love this. So many thought provoking questions came to my mind when I first read this and each time I read it I come to love it more and more.
    Beautiful. "