Comments : My Manila Prince

  • 11 years ago

    by Poet on the Piano

    What really enticed me right away was the title.... the only reference I myself know of "manila" is for a manila envelope. So I googled this and found out that Manila is the capital and largest city of the Philippines. I guessed you were from there then saw on your profile you are.

    I love the ease of this piece and your consistent structure, how each word flows into the next. There were just a few places I believe could be worked on for adding punctuation and making sure your thoughts are being understood.

    "To know that
    Manila cannot hold
    those Paris stars
    and that Paris
    will not let
    my dreams glitter
    underneath its sky,
    I have known
    how it feels
    to dance under
    the Manila sky
    where my dreams
    will always be
    coloured ornately."

    - Okay two things.
    1) When you begin your stanza with "to know that", you never finish that thought. With regards to the word structure it should read something like "to know that........ saddens me" or any other verb.

    2) I like how "in touch" and personal you get here. Speaking of Paris then Manila as if they are both a part of you. They are both cities I have never been to, yet I feel this yearning in you. It makes me think you visited Paris prior to living in Manila, and that there is a tangible distance. You feel you cannot expand these dreams under Manila's sky. Beautifully expressed here.

    "You keep believing
    that the reason
    why a tower
    that is named after
    Gustave Eiffel
    stood formidably
    in the city
    where your reveries
    are hidden
    is for you
    to make promises
    under its stars."

    - Fourth line: You need punctuation here. There are certain natural pauses that one takes due to the fact you are writing a longer line. Either shorten it or put in commas, otherwise, it's too long and doesn't make as much sense. It's too long-winded.

    Love the use of "reveries" near the end and that actual inclusion of the founder of that iconic tower. It reminded me of how universal that symbol is, yet how I never imagined a character contemplating its reason for being there- its purpose.

    "For eight hours,
    I kept re-reading
    the phrases
    that you left written
    at the doorstep
    of our house
    that morning-
    hoping that
    those phrases
    would be enough
    to let me know
    that every Manila star
    would embrace me
    at twilight.
    (But I did not find
    their embrace...
    instead, your farewell
    has reached me
    that twilight)"

    - I feel you have too many "that's" here; it almost makes it complicated to read.

    "For eight hours,
    I kept re-reading
    the phrases
    that you left written
    at the doorstep"

    - Do you need to say "left written"? I think it is implied since you say they are letter.

    Also, the "that" at the ending line almost makes it more impersonal. It also appears you shift tenses. "has reached me that night", present then saying "that night" means in the past. You could say "your farewell reached me at twilight" or change to present depending on if it's one night or many times you are reliving this goodbye.

    "No matter
    how days stir
    my fate
    that is tied
    to this place
    and yours
    that is caged in Paris,
    you'll always
    be the one
    who loves Paris
    more than
    this place."

    - Intriguing thought and good tie-in with Paris as well. It is the preferred city, like there is an unfinished dream waiting there. I actually think your usage of "that" is important here and significant in conveying the difference between where your fate is and where this person's fate is.

    "I'm sorry
    that Manila
    cannot hide
    your reveries
    for its palms
    are too tiny
    to be your throne,

    My Manila Prince."

    - Great ending! That hint of sorrow and sympathy, as well as maybe a tone of bitterness? I'm not sure. I got the feel at the end that this person either dreamed so much that you believed it clouded their reality (for you were the realist)... or that they didn't want to give this city a chance.

    Unique piece, thanks for sharing

  • 11 years ago

    by Burning Angel

    I loved this title and it made the poem more amazing. Great write