Comments : Yuki

  • 11 years ago

    by Meena Krish

    I can feel the authentic flavor of this write. I like how you have given snow beauty and character..admiring her beauty like an artist waiting to draw her elegance..beautiful read!

  • 11 years ago

    by Sylvia

    I am not a professional writer or poet so what I have commented here are my own personal thoughts and feelings. Dashiel, it seems as if you might have been in a hurry to write this poem, not sure but I have read your work and this one is a little to rough as it is written. I think it needs to be rewritten, keeping the some thoughts and ideas for the poem but rearranging them, making them smoother (less stiff feeling), use less filler words. You could probably shorten it as some thoughts are repeated in several of places. You have a good foundation for this poem and just need to build on it.

    The idea that snow has forgotten its color because the snow thinks it is a frozen flower is original. Nice thoughts that the person you care about has "combined" all the fun you have had together and reminds you of snowflakes dancing in the wind. Your dreams are "snow covered" by those flakes. Once the ground is blanketed by snow, the beauty is like thousands of silent flowers that never had their stories told. You feel that the person you care about is a canvas of thoughts and feelings, good and bad and you are waiting to dream those dreams. You refer again how the person has pulled all the fun and memories together, that keeps you content and happy especially watching the snowfall. In the last verse I think the idea is that reality comes back to view, everyone remembers who they are, where they are and you will always remember them when you watch the snow falling.

    VERSE ONE
    This verse is rough in the way your thoughts are presented. We can take poetic license with many things but saying Snow is white because it is a white Camellia frozen is a stretch.

    VERSE TWO
    I see where you brought the Snow is white idea to this verse. Snow has forgotten its own color because it thinks it is a flower.

    VERSE THREE
    Starts as if you are talking about a person and comparing their actions to the snowfall

    VERSE FOUR
    Switches to dreams

    VERSE FIVE
    Back to the snowfall and the flowers building a scene

    VERSE SIX
    Back to the person and their thoughts, feelings regarding you

    VERSE SEVEN
    Started with almost the same words as verse three, need to change those in one of the verses, the word reveries is used at least 3 times in the poem. Find a synonym for "reveries" and change all but one of the instances. It detracts from the poem to use the same word more than once although at times we have no choice but in this case, I think there is a choice.

    VERSE EIGHT
    This is where things can get touchy. You can wait until the end and use a last verse to pull all the ideas, thoughts, feelings together and finalize them or during the rewrite you can arrange the words and lines so that they are pulled together as you go along. Then verse eight is eliminated.

  • 11 years ago

    by Everlasting

    All right, I have forgotten how to comment. hehe

    So here goes my opinion and perhaps a few suggestions for your poem. Just like Sylvia I'm not a pro, so it's only my views. At the end of the day, you are the author so based on the given comments you may decide what works best for your poems. :)

    Okay....

    Snow is white
    because it is
    really a
    white Camellia-
    a frozen one,
    a precipitation
    on a
    wintery sky.

    --- On this first stanza, "it is really" at least for me.. it's not strong. So I'm not believing what you are telling per se. My suggestion is to change it to "it is in fact." --> Now based on this, I'm going to continue reading the rest of your poem to see how you are going to prove it to me. Though, in a way you have already done so in this stanza, by comparing it to a white Camellia and then by telling me that is a frozen one, however, I'm curious to see what's next because I'm not fully believing it yet [ though I like the idea ;) and the image ]

    Here is my suggestion incorporated:

    Snow is white
    because it is in fact
    a white Camellia-
    a frozen one,
    a precipitation
    on a wintery sky

    *******************

    It has
    forgotten its
    own color
    and assumed
    to be
    a flower
    as eternal
    as the
    eastern sky.

    ---- This stanza is a bit rocky to read. Specially after "and assumed" So perhaps, work towards connecting those two ideas better. Also I don't see how snow forgot its own color.. even if it is a flower... it is white. So in a sense the color did not change. What changed was its own identity. So here is my suggestion:

    who has forgotten
    it's identity.
    And assumed
    to be a flower
    as eternal as
    the eastern sky.

    --- It ties down with the idea of the snow being a flower. It's still cold and white because its a frozen white flower according to the first stanza. Now if you read the first and second stanza, they go hand on hand.

    ***********************

    You knitted
    our reveries
    together and
    made it
    fall like
    snowflakes dancing
    in the
    Daisy-scented breeze.

    -- I would change the structure of this stanza a little bit more like this plus I would change "the Daisy" into "a Daisy " :

    You knitted
    our reveries together
    and made it fall
    like snowflakes
    dancing in a Daisy-
    scented breeze

    -- I'm going to change the structure of the other stanzas, and a few words so just take a look at it. If you have any question as to why I would change it some way to another, feel free to ask me. I would need to read the poems a couple of more times to fully understand what you are saying. There are parts that confused me, because you change from narrating to speaking to someone. So I would suggests to use ---- this lines to separate and give the reader a little more time to grasp what you are saying. .I use those lines --- probably not in the right spots but it will be easier for you to do that. I enjoy the poem. Keep writing.

    *******************************

    Here is how I would structure it. . . You don't have to change your poem, it's only a suggestion.

    Snow is white
    because it is in fact
    a white Camellia-
    a frozen one,
    a precipitation
    on a wintery sky

    that has forgotten
    it's identity.
    And assumed
    to be a flower
    as eternal as
    the eastern sky.

    ---

    You knitted
    our reveries together
    and made it fall
    like snowflakes
    dancing in a Daisy-
    scented breeze

    Now every dream
    is snow-capped.
    (Like my dreams of
    being with you)

    ----

    And when the ground
    is covered with snow,
    it describes beauty
    like listing down
    a thousand flowers
    that never get to tell
    their winter tales
    on a crumpled paper.

    ---

    After eating enough
    gray and blue, you are a canvas
    hibernating. You forget
    I am still here
    waiting to paint you
    the crimson snow
    in my dreams.

    You knit our reveries
    together, you make
    them fall like snow...

    And even though
    it is only those reveries
    that keep me warm,
    I want the falling of
    the snow
    to be incessant.

    ----

    When the snow
    remembers
    what its real color is,
    I will plant a
    white Camellia
    in your eyes...

    for you
    to always remember
    that even
    snow as white
    as the dancing clouds,
    owns a flower's purity
    and forgets
    its own clarity
    to remember
    that falling
    is something white
    to begin with.

    (And snow
    does fall)