Comments : Why Her?

  • 18 years ago

    by PassionatelyMarla

    Ur poem is really good, i feel the pain that u talk of,, keep it up!
    and wont u pls read mine, i think u will like it, thx

  • 18 years ago

    by DevilWithin

    I like this alot very nice, I can see the sorrow she has felt. xox Rachel

  • 18 years ago

    by Tiffani

    AwEsOmE aWeSoMe AWESOME POEM!!! i swear if i didnt know better this was about a girl in my grade named Aly, wow we seem a lot alike.

    Keep writing,
    Stay strong,
    Love Tiffani

  • 18 years ago

    by InvisibleGurl

    Hey Claire!!

    Seems just like one of my friends at school! (Oooh shouldn't be speaking bad about her lol) but yeah, she flirts with everyone... just so true.. !!

    Especially loved the last verse:
    "I don't know why it's attractive
    I don't know what the guys see
    So boys can you please tell me
    Why her and not me?"

    Though the last line of the first verse doesn't seem to fit...:I know what you mean, but the wording doesn't seem quite right.
    "It's always just her
    She just so good
    I'll now explain
    The way it should "

    Just my opinion, that is...
    Overall great poem xoxox
    Laterz,
    Shirlz.

  • 18 years ago

    by SoRrOwFuL Claire

    Yeah everyone can see the sorrow she felt but she didnt care how much she screwed my life up and she's done this before many times to many of my friends. so i thought its my right to let ppl now how wacked out she is

  • 18 years ago

    by .x.PorteR.x.

    Hey my beautiful, it's Porter :)

    You gotta get your butt online and explain this too me, coz i know exactly who you're talking about but i didn't know she had taken anyone from you... i'll talk to you soon, i really want to find out...

    Bye bye my sweetie,
    xx, Porter.

  • 18 years ago

    by .x.PorteR.x.

    I'm back Claire, to actually comment on the poem this time, because that seemed to slip my mind before...

    Okay, i really really like it, especially the last verse. I think you finish it off really well, and i love the way you ended with a rhetorical question! *claps*

    But, just one thing babe:
    "She takes the guys she likes
    When you like them too
    She doesn't even care
    What it'll do to you"

    For some reason i don't like the wording of the last line. It may just be a weird thing that i have but for some reason i think it would sound better like "What it does to you", just for the rhythm. But i'm just weird about rhythm-things so just ignore this if you want to, okay beautiful?

    Bye bye Claire,
    xox,
    Porter.

  • 18 years ago

    by aimee

    That was really strong ur very talented and i wish i was half the writer u r, stay strong

    peace ^_^
    @my

  • 18 years ago

    by Angie

    Really strong poem and very well written! I really loved the last stanza! It was amazing! The only part which i found didn't quite work so well is:

    "It's always just her
    She just so good
    I'll now explain
    The way it should "

    I don't know why, it just doesn't flow..... Maybe you could say something like:

    "It's just always her,
    Only because she seems pretty.
    But let me explain,
    The way it should be."

    I dunno just a suggestion! =) Overal though this poem is wonderful and very well written! Keep up the awesome work! 5/5
    ~Luvz~
    ~Angie~
    xoxo