Comments : My friend the solider

  • 18 years ago

    by Jerrys¤baby¤girl

    Thats really sad... im sry to hear that something like that had to happen..
    Love always Tiffany Heather
    Great POem

  • 18 years ago

    by Natasha

    I have been wanting to write a poem about the sholdiers who don't make it home for a long time. Yet I doubt I could ever achieve something like what you put down.
    It's amazing how you are able to capture the thought and pain of the people close. It's just that good.

    ~*TasH*~

  • 18 years ago

    by REX

    Bloody excelant well done

    love

    rex

  • 18 years ago

    by Nicholas Sun

    O_O whoa........

  • 18 years ago

    by Neil

    That is so sad julie my goodness
    hmm my cousin is a US marine nd well i know how sad it is that hes gone nd riskin his life

    i like it specially the choice of words

  • 18 years ago

    by pseudo

    Wow.. beautifully written poem.. so much emotion in to it.. very well written.. i am very sorry for your loss.. this is a very vivid poem and i can picture some of these images that you described its like you've painted this picture.. this is an amazing poem.. with such strong and powerful words.. great work =)

    --emotionless19*

  • 18 years ago

    by firexflys

    Wow iam sooo very sorry about your friend. amazing poem. keep up the good work

  • 18 years ago

    by Void

    Wow, that was really good. The story was really well told and it was sweet to have that kind of tribute. There's one thing you may want to fix tho - this tiny little insignificant error in spelling:

    Your fellow 'solider'

    to 'soldier'

    hehe but that doesn't even count as a poetic error. So other than that, don't change a thing in this :)

  • 18 years ago

    by Emma

    Wow! i cant explain the feelings i get. i have a family member and a friend in iraq. it was just great. Keep up the great work.

    Emma 5/5

  • 18 years ago

    by Vegetable

    It's very good overall but I found little things that distract from the effect. When you say "As your casket walks by" It made me imagine a casket with legs...which sort of ruined the whole tone. Maybe say as the casket was carried by or something.
    In the line "Your body to mangled" to should be too. and in the line "Of once a young happy you" I think you mean for a and once to be switched.
    Then in the 5th stanza the rhythm is a little off and the last line seems a little blunt and the rest of the poem clearly conveys that he fought in the war... stating it ruins it a little. Then in the next stanza I don't really understand what you are trying to get across.. If you want to show that this is where the body is it doesn't make sence to say that it arrived there before it was "led" or brought. forgive me for picking apart your poem, I'm trying to be helpful so you don't need to listen to me. But I'm very sorry for your loss.. It's particularly sad when a young life is just thrown away in war.

  • 18 years ago

    by lee

    Omg that's so sad. my boyfriends in the army. and I loved this poem. 5/5

  • 18 years ago

    by xDryTearsx

    This poem is so sad . i really almost cried
    i cant see clear cuz my eyes are starting to water. o.O

  • 18 years ago

    by t. h a l l i d a y *

    Wow really good ....

  • 18 years ago

    by NissY

    A good one.
    You did draw a good picture of the whole situation, but what Lorraine stated in her comment was somehow true.

    I aint saying am better either, but what I do is let the words flow out onto the sheet, and then re read it and try to re construct it; but hey, don't change too much, or the poem will loose out on the spontaneous part.

    Apart from that, Love reading your work.

  • 18 years ago

    by VampyraKi†

    Wow that is truly amazing

  • 18 years ago

    by *Sherrie*

    Im sorry you had to go through that, but this is a great poem, from what I have read you are an amazing poet, Im looking forward to reading more of your work
    xox Sherrie

  • 18 years ago

    by Ria

    It's a great poem, I don't know your point of view, but partiots or not, they are all men who deserve to live, I'd prefer to see those soldiers live in peace that stand for aa already safe country.Well done to you

  • 18 years ago

    by Tainted Beauty

    Aww! This poem almost made me cry, especially the last stanza! Great work on this, it's so sad that soliders die so pointlessly, it breaks my heart everytime i hear of a soldier dying. Great work

    --Steph