What Should I Do?

What should I do,
When I love two?

When I am with one, for the other I long,
I can't find a place for my heart to belong.

You promised that you would always stay,
But now you have gone away.

Your love to me was as clear as a bell,
You promised that I'd always be your Angel.

We used to love each other so very much,
but you were blinded by another girl's touch.

But now I have found someone new,
And he loves me like you used to do.

And now you say I am right for you,
but with only half my heart do I love you.

Now I must choose between both of you,
I am so confused, I don't know what to do.

What should I do,
When I love two?