Comments : How It Was

  • 17 years ago

    by Mr M

    Too long and repetative. not your best piece but still, the value of what you write is worth high marks....good job!

  • 17 years ago

    by Ike Dizzle

    Aww that's sad but sweet. great job. 5/5
    -vino

  • 17 years ago

    by Marc Ortiz

    I like the use of repetition in the poem ;) Just a suggestion to use punctuations it will really improve your poems. It flowed well =)

    Now we are (split)
    A suggestion.. change it to.. (apart)

    Us together was in heaven whenever we was together
    ^^ That doesn't make sense to me.. sorry (maybe you need to rephrase it.)

    We had a taste of heaven (Paradise)
    We touched heaven
    We stretched for heaven and got there as one
    Us together was in heaven whenever we was together

    ^^ You repeated heaven 4 times xD I'm not saying it's good.. But I think it would be better if you try using different words =)

    It (hasnt) from me = hasn't

    And capitalize the I's =)

    PS. Sorry if you don't like constructive criticism.

    You may not change your poem if you don’t want to =)

    Nonetheless.. It was a great poem. Keep up the fantastic work.

  • 17 years ago

    by Marc Ortiz

    ^^ You repeated heaven 4 times xD I'm not saying i(t's) = isn't good.. But I think it would be better if you try using different words =)
    ^^ Sorry for the typo

  • 17 years ago

    by Tears May Fall

    Thats a good poem

  • 17 years ago

    by Kayla

    Katy, this is a very lovely poem sweetie =) You did a good job.. it was full of love, sadness, and painful memories of a broken relationship.
    The only thing though, is that you need to clean it up alittle bit.. like you use "was" a lot when it should be "were". And you should add some periods at the ends of your lines =) It just makes the poem look a lot neater and it looks more professional..

    Great job, please keep up the good work!

    ~Loveless Nights~

  • 17 years ago

    by Tay

    Amazing poem
    The many emotions you portrayed really amazed me. It's sadly beautiful was written well.
    Nice Job!!
    -Taylore

  • 17 years ago

    by loviin hym

    5/5

  • 17 years ago

    by Loved In Hell

    I can relate i hate livng in the past but i do

    anyways great job and keept it up i like this poem alot
    5/5
    laura

  • 17 years ago

    by Delirium

    Wow that was really good.Long but really good!lol Keep it up i love your poems!

  • 17 years ago

    by TheQuestioner

    It sounds kind of like the situation i was in but hes just started coming back to me... great peom.
    TheQuestioner
    ~Dollie~

  • 17 years ago

    by Mr M

    Poems that are long tend to lose the readers attention after about thirty lines...just a bug in your ear there....

  • 17 years ago

    by ABake

    Well, you really need to change all of the was's to were.
    The length was kind of long.
    But I can feel your pain.
    Great job!
    4/5
    XxAmberxX

  • 17 years ago

    by Tammi

    I love this poem and I feel ur pain and loss for this person for as u read my poems so u know that I to have lost someone I love alot any how great flow and love it 5/5

  • 17 years ago

    by Christina Yap

    I love this poem mainly because i can relate. I feel that you repeating lines emphasizes your feelings. keep writing 5/5

  • 17 years ago

    by Hebe

    Good poem.
    Little bit long.
    How longer the poem how more people must do their best to keep their attention.
    But besides that, I really like it.
    Well done.
    Take care

  • 17 years ago

    by x Mo x

    That was very beautiful and very full of emotion, but I think it was very long. I really enjoyed reading it. I have never read anything more beautiful. Very good write! Keep it up! Ill read some more of your poems!

    ~Mo~

  • 17 years ago

    by Han84

    Hey yeah nicely written hun....
    bit long but however i liked it alot.. but if this is what went on in ya life let me just say this "ONE DOOR SHUTS AND ANOTHER ONE WILL OPEN"

    so jus go with flow an ull move on in time

    take care

  • 17 years ago

    by Angel0fDaRK11

    This was a great poem, it just had a great flow :]

  • 17 years ago

    by MiiZZy A

    Really kute!!
    i luv it