You broke my heart into pieces, then you gave it back to me. But then I noticed that one piece was still missing. The piece you still have... the piece that you're still playing with.

On the outside I'm pushing you away
But inside I'm wishing for you to stay
As I tell you to leave, you don't know
That my heart is screaming please don't go

What I would give to be her for one day
To hold you in my arms, to hear you say
That we would always be together
And you'd be in love with me forever
I would do anything, if I could find a way
To be her for just one day

I watch my friend tell me that she's glad that I've moved on. "I'm proud of you for getting rid of him like that. Who needs him anyway?" she says, and walks away. A tear trickles down my cheek as I whisper... "I do"

Theres still a part of me that wishes you would call
Theres still a time in the night when a teardrop falls
Theres still a pain in me that never really ends
But I'll just smile at you and continue to pretend...

Plaster on a smile and pretend that you're okay
Lie and say your happy as you wipe the tears away
Hide the hurt you feel inside so nobody will know
That even after all this time you haven't let him go

Tell me, please... Just look into my tear-filled eyes and answer the one simple question that has been gnawing at my heart since the day you left...

What happened to forever?

"I'm happy for you," I smile
As I look him in the eye...
But when I turn around
The tears stream down
For I know it's just a lie...

If I could hate him I would... I promise. The only problem is, that there's this part of me that still sees the guy that I once knew... The guy that he pretended to be.

I'll wave at him and walk right by
Smiling with tears in my eye
I'll try my hardest to pretend
That to me he's "just a friend"
For if I hide it, he won't know
That I still haven't let him go