Need a heart transplant

There are five people they all need a heart transplant which one will you give it to:
1.a black female who is a doctor
2. a white 17 yr old girl who is a drop out
3. a white 37 yr old who is close to finding the cure for aides and a lesbian.
4 a 12 yr olf up coming musician
5 a catholic priest

No lets just say you are a doctor that has to choose who you want to have the heart which one

And why do you picked the lesbain

What about the little girl she stills have a life to live

They're all worthy of life.

The twelve year old or the seventeen year old who has not yet even learned about life

Yep you are so right

You can save one little girl.. or someone who has (almost found) the cure for aids? and by saving her and not the 12/17 year old, potentially saving thousands of lives?

You have to think about it like this: one little girl, or tons of grown men, women, elderly, and children, from poverty stricken countries or everyday life who have aids.

Yeah, they all have a right to a life, but you have to think of the big picture. I agree with the tasteless, even though it's not because she's a lesbian.

It doesn't matter gender, race, religion or colour, it's what you DO that makes you a good or a bad person.

WHo's to say what one little girl can amount to : )

But do we know for sure? she could be just another ordinary little girl who can't save thousands of people from a disease.

you have to go for the definite thing in situations like these.

17 year old girl, I mean I literally gave her a heart she at least owes me a date.

I'd close my eyes and pick one.

3 cuz shes close to finding the cure for aids. i love my lesbians/gays, afterall i am half les...=]

if i could save 2 id pick 4 as well, because hes so young with great potential =]

No one? Because I'm still using it.

AHH! too hard. i'd play eeny meeny miny mo. cuz i can't decide. >.<

#3

4 sacrifices are easy enough to make when holding the fate of roughly 33 million people.

Easy enough.

I'd give 'em all my heart. No one deserves to die. Even the drop out deserves to live. She made a mistake or two. So have I. So have you. Difference is some people just give up and that's so sad.

I'd choose 1 or 3, i'm not racist for either lesbian or black....both are going to save millions of lives. Heres why i didn't choose the others.

2. a white 17 yr old girl who is a drop out
As she is a drop out.... i'm going to be sterotypical of most of the drop outs i've mett.....i'm not at all speaking for all of them. Most of the dropouts i've met, either mooch of the government or go into drug dealing and have a bazzilion kids that they could care less about. It's true she hasn't begun to live...but she doesn't seem to be heading down a good road.

4 a 12 yr olf up coming musician
This one was a hard one, i don't really care about the fact that she wanted to be a musican.....kids change their minds all the time......

5 a catholic priest
The church is in need of priests....and assuming he hasn't done dirty to innocent children, I would have said save him too....but then i thought......he's already super holy....why would he need to live a long time more?? He's already got a spot in heaven. Priests also don't have wives or kids to live for....they live for god...so he'd just go to god sooner....?

I'd pick the one who may find the cure for AIDS.
That person has the potential to save so many lives.

But race has nothing to do with anything, and neither does being gay or straight.

Hmm.
I've never thought of it that way sam, but true.

I only said that i chose the doctor not because she is a lesbian but because of what she may be capable of because the original poster clearly said their race and sexuality as though that would change your mind.

I do agree that their race/sexuality has nothing to do with this, nor age or colour.

^^^
Lol. they all do. that's the point of the question: You have to make a choice.