In Love with two?

Is it possible to be in love with two people at the same time? Or is it possible to still have feelings for someone at the same time love another? I am so confused right now. My heart is in two seperate places or better yet with two different people. I am In LOVE with one and I like another. I used to love that one person but after she moved Its not the same. I found this guy that I am so in love with and he makes me feel like everything is going to be alright. But that girl is moving back down here and I am totally scared that what if when we hangout again that what if like my feelings for her start to re-surface. I have no idea what I should do. I don't wanna give her up because she is my best friend but I also don't want to give up my boyfriend because I care about him deeply...What should I do? Or how should I go about this situation? The two do not like one another so I cannot hangout with them at the same time which sucks but I just do not know what to do. Please help!??

I think ultimately it comes down to who do you care about more. Who's been there more? Who do you love more? You can't love both, well you might feel like it now, but you can't go on loving both. Be with one person, then maybe if it works out you can be friends with the other. But you must figure out who's who first.

I have been thinking about it a lot lately and I think that I just want to be friends with her. But I sometimes think like well what if we become like best friends again and like I start feeling for her again. You know? But I do love him a lot more and I can't go a day without him. When I am not with him he is all I can seem to think about.