Weekly Judges - Nominations

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Every six months, we swap out our current 5 site judges for new judges. The next rotation is in September.
    The job requires commitment and free time. All poems on the nominations page must be read and considered by each judge, then their individually-picked top 3 choices must be messaged privately with points and comments every Sunday to whoever is in charge of posting contest results. Judges are given the power to place their votes themselves.

    Many people have found and will find themselves overwhelmed by the workload, but their contribution to the site is momentous and appreciated.

    Being a judge means being unbiased and thick-skinned. An ideal judge possesses good judgment, a sound comprehension of poetry, and a determination to uphold the standards of quality on PnQ.

    We have no current restrictions or rules denoting who is fit to hold the position.
    There is no age limit.

    Judges will not be repeated if it can be helped, but most of you do not know who has judged and who is judging. Therefore, nominating poets is a somewhat blind task, but it is extremely helpful for the moderators.

    In this thread, nominate as many poets as you like. These will be our candidates. Please be realistic and pick people who would be well-suited for the job. If your name is nominated, post whether you accept or decline the nomination. If your name is not nominated, nominate it yourself. Poets with the most nominations will be considered the most seriously.
    * Also, please write the poet's screen name, not their actual name. Unfortunately I may think they are two different people if I am given two different names :)
    Thank you!

    X counts for 1 vote.
    Candidates:

    Accepted -
    Britt XXXXXXXXXXX
    The Poetess XXXXXXX
    Ms Sunshine XXXXXXX
    Rabea Jadallah XXXXX
    Sylvia X
    Ingrid XX
    Colm XX
    Courageous Dreamer XXXXXXX

    Awaiting -
    ABC XXXXXXXXX
    Lady Nik XX
    Karla X
    Mel X
    Melissa XXXX
    The Prince XXX
    Luanne XX
    StandStill X
    Italian Stallion XXX
    Novalyn Grace XX
    Yaki XXXX
    Meena Krish XX
    Thomas Pender X

    Declined -
    slighte XX
    Melpomene XXXXXXXX
    Mera Luna XXXXXXXXXXXXXX
    Abby XXX
    Jad X
    Narphangu XXXXXXXX
    Hellon aka Miss Take XXXX
    The Queen XXXX
    Liquid Grace XX
    Hold Your Heart XXXXX
    Nicko XX
    xLilMissFrostyx X
    Lady Aureus Argentum XX
    Lebanese Phoenix XXX
    Jordan XX
    Beautiful Chaos XXXX
    Edward X
    Kiko XXXXXXX
    The Princess XXXXXXXXXX

    EDIT:
    Members no longer on this site will not be included in the list. I have probably included some that aren't here so correct me. Also, I think there would be too much controversy over having a moderator as a weekly judge, so for now I will leave moderators out :)

    If you are a current judge, you don't need to accept or decline unless you want to be trixy and throw people off. You will be swapped out at the end of August no matter what.

  • Britt
    13 years ago

    I vote for Narphangu.

  • nouriguess
    13 years ago

    Thanks, Jane! :)

    I nominate:

    -Lady Nik.
    -Nana
    -Courageous Dreamer (Temps)
    -Rabea Jadallah
    -Auzy
    -Mera Luna
    and ME! :):)

  • The Queen
    13 years ago

    Jane, I think there is a mistake up there, it's The Poetess instead of The Princess, I'm not sure though.

    Ok, I nominate:

    Britt
    Abby
    Hellon
    Karla
    Narph
    Melpomene
    Edward
    Mera Luna
    Kiko
    Beautiful Chaos
    Colm
    Melissa
    Auzy (I'm not sure if he's available)
    The Princess

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Yes, that was my bad. Thank you for pointing it out! I'll add your nominations.

    P.S. Judges will be selected toward the end of August. Time flies, so get your nominations in now and accept or decline as soon as possible.

  • AJ
    13 years ago

    Narph
    Britt
    Abby
    Mel

    There's my votes.

  • Britt
    13 years ago

    I..aye, aye. I suppose I'll accept.

  • Sunshine
    13 years ago

    I am sorry, i made my votes in the other thread, on phone and didnt see this...

    ok i said:

    ingrid
    nano
    sylvia
    brit
    the queen
    Mel
    ABc
    hellon

    ^^^^^^
    i agree.

  • Narphangu
    13 years ago

    Haha, I'm always reading the nominations and guessing which ones will win.
    In light of that, I accept. :)

    I nominate:

    Britt
    Courageous Dreamer
    Mera Luna
    ABC

  • Sunshine
    13 years ago

    ...sorry couldnt edit

    definitely:
    narph
    mera luna
    bob shank
    temp
    laryy [The godfather]

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    By "I agree," do you mean you accept, Nana?

    Keep me in line guys, let me know if the votes are wrong.

  • Sherry Lynn
    13 years ago

    The Prince

    Lu

    Hold your heart

    StandStill

    xLilMissFrostyx

    Italian Stallion

  • abracadabra
    13 years ago

    The Princess
    Narph
    Mera Luna
    Nicko
    Melissa
    The Prince

    It's a bloody pain in the arse being a judge, so a respectful no thanks to those kind souls who nominated me.

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    For my own part so you guys know what votes I've cast...

    Narphangu
    Britt
    Rabea Jadallah
    ABC
    Mera Luna
    Hellon aka Miss Take
    Beautiful Chaos
    Melissa
    The Princess
    Nicko
    Jordan
    Novalyn Grace RR
    Yaki Love
    Meena Krish
    Kiko
    slighte

  • Melpomene
    13 years ago

    I was going to say Abby, but as she's declined..

    Narph
    Myryn (The Queen)
    Cynnie (Mera Luna)
    Auzy (ABC)
    Melissa
    Hellon
    Britt

  • RSJ
    13 years ago

    Can we nominate a Mod?
    if so then my picks would be

    Brit
    ABC
    the poetss^noura)
    sunshine
    and silvershoes
    also ingrid

    and sure, i'll accept the nomination =-)

  • abracadabra
    13 years ago

    Oh, please add Kiko, Jordan and slighte to my mix.

    I sound a tad ungracious in my response earlier, sorry! Hungover.

  • Liquid Grace
    13 years ago

    I nominate:

    Mera Luna
    The Princess
    The Queen
    Beautiful Chaos
    ABC
    Thomas Pender ( I'm unsure if he's available. I have sent him a PM to let him know of this thread.)
    Melpomene

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Great! I'm nervous I have the votes wrong so if someone could double-check at some point, that'd be awesome.

    Rabea, at this point I am excluding moderators but thank you for the nomination.

  • Sylvia
    13 years ago

    I accept

    I nominate Austin, Ms Sunshine

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Think we're up to date so far.

  • Ingrid
    13 years ago

    I accept the nomination( thanks for who voted for me!)

    I nominate:

    Nana
    Rabea
    ABC
    Danny
    Norhan
    Nano
    Amanda
    Britt
    Kiko
    Mel
    MaryAnne ( Hold your heart)
    MeraLuna
    Jacey

    I may add more names lateron, will make a new post then. ( I didn't mention anyone whom I know will decline for sure or have done so already)

  • The Queen
    13 years ago

    Amanda
    Italian Stallion

    And thanks for the votes, but I'm afraid I'll have to decline :( This has been a very busy year for me, though I don't mind doing it next year :)

  • Decayed
    13 years ago

    - The Poetess
    - Ms Sunshine
    - Hold Your Heart

  • nouriguess
    13 years ago

    I'll add: Brianna, Myryn and Nor, please. :)

  • Sunshine
    13 years ago

    Ya accept...agree...lol.
    and sorry bout bob, did not know!

  • Courageous Dreamer
    13 years ago

    Narphangu
    Colm
    Mera Luna
    The Princess
    Novalyn
    Kiko

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    No problem. Updated.

    Again, guys, please use screen names because I'm afraid I don't know everyone's "real" names, so it makes it hard to tally votes.

    What is Brianna's screen name?

  • Courageous Dreamer
    13 years ago

    I believe she means Lady Aureus Argentum.

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Thank you so much!

  • Courageous Dreamer
    13 years ago

    I spelled it wrong originally, you may want to check it.

  • silvershoes
    13 years ago

    Perhaps tomorrow... I'm going to sleep. Goodnight :)

  • nouriguess
    13 years ago

    Yeah, true, Temps. I meant her.

    I vote for:

    Jane (Silvershoes)
    Hold Your Heart

  • Larry Chamberlin
    13 years ago

    My votes:

    Britt
    The Poetess
    Ms Sunshine
    Rabea Jadallah
    The Princess

  • Sherry Lynn
    13 years ago

    Hellon, I did a copy and paste from my cell phone. It is not. Very easy and something that I have just recently learned to do.

  • Colm
    13 years ago

    My votes:

    Mera Luna
    Courageous Dreamer
    The Princess
    Kiko

    I accept nominations, Id be up for being a judge

  • Sherry Lynn
    13 years ago

    Again, Hellon, I accidentally copied his name with the others from the best critique list.

    When I realized it I fixed it.

    I apologize for the human error.

    I do almost everything from my cell phone and, yes, I make mistakes.

  • Sunshine
    13 years ago

    As for me being the someone who nominated bob, i did not know that he left, cause i have been busy with the life i have away from the net. just been signing in to talk with my members/assist. for a moment to make sure that they know i am still around... and i picked bob cause he fits, and i am disappoiiinted to know he left while i?was busy with finals cause he was about to help me edit a poem when i am done.

    :p

  • Sherry Lynn
    13 years ago

    Not just by looking at the list...

    Hellon, what is the real issue here? What does it matter how or why I THOUGHT of judges to simply NOMINATE?

    There is more to this and I feel that you are nit picking at me because I offended you or something.

    I should not have to explain how I made a copy and paste error. I made one, end of story.

    Answer to your question, dear Hellon... About an hour ago for me.

  • Narphangu
    13 years ago

    Hey, sorry to do this (especially since I already accepted), but I'm realizing that I'll be starting as a freshman in September and I'm honestly not sure how much time I'll have for this. I don't want to compromise the site if it turns out I'm too busy, so I'll have to decline after all. :(

    But thank you all for the nominations. I'd love to do it next year. :)