RESULTS!
I will list by points, and then the comments:
1. Beats - 10, 7, 9 (+5BP) = 31
2. Dalliance - 6, 7, 10 (+5BP) = 28
3. Lost at Sea - 9, 5, 8 (+5BP) = 27
4. Rockin' To The 50's - 7, 7, 7 (+5BP) = 26
5. Standing Ovation - 6, 8, 6 (+5BP) = 25
6. Equinox - 5, 6, 8 (+5BP) = 24
7. Me Vuelves Loco - 7, 6, 6 (+5BP) = 24
8. Bordello Alley - 6, 5, 6 (+5BP) = 22
9. Untitled - 5, 4, 8 = 17
``````````````````````````````````````
BEATS:
WOW! Morbid expression of domestic violence. The stark contrast between reality ("mango colored cheeks" caused by bruising) and the fiction (painting her bruises to hide them) expresses the true nature of one caught in the cycle of violence - unable to seek help, ashamed of being the victim, remaining in the worst situation because she does not believe she can escape. As magnificently portrayed as it is horrible in its content.
10/10
This was interesting in that it differed from the other entries in that it held a sense of danger and menace: the dance is not a romantic, positive experience here but a dangerous one. It has both literal and metaphorical meaning and a nice balance is struck between them them. The almost narraive/recount style helps enhance the poems message/impact, but at times is a little too 'telling' and explanitory in the second half. First off, I thought the woman was a prostitute, but on second reading and the bruises every night, it is probably a victim of domestic violence with an abusive, controlling boyfriend. All in all, I appreciate the original take on the task by making it a dark, serious poem and succeeding in doing so, despite not containing overly 'poetic' language or phraseology. The double meaning in the title is also note-worthy. Well done. 7/10
This is such a haunting, powerful and startling poem from the viewpoint of one being abused. Also a very powerful example of how words can tell a compelling story. 9/10
```````````````````````````````````````
DALLIANCE
This quite succinctly describes how mind blowing an unexpected display of femininity can be to a distracted young man. Beautiful image created by "hips hook and instantly create a tropical hail storm."
6/10
This short poem worked quite well and its power lies in its relative brevity. I like the use of the word 'vine' as a verb: it is creative and descriptive. Also, a good effort is made to portray the feel of the dance and replicate that tone on paper. Every word seems to have meaning and no words are wasted, which is a positive thing. The switch in tone and pace in the second stanza is good but almost too contrasting: and I'm not sure if the use of 'gulf of casualness' works, because in this frenzied dance there seems no place for mention of calmness. Overall though the poem is quite well crafted and and is an interesting read. 7/10
What I find beautiful in this poem is the author's use of carefully chosen words in order to describe aspects of a scene or emotions in an interesting and coherent order. In the first half of the poem, the author gives the mundane its beautiful due while in the second half, the use of juxtaposition is something unsuspected, which makes this poem an enjoyable read. 10/10
`````````````````````````````````````
LOST AT SEA
The art discussed can be taken literally or as a metaphor for the mental attitude of the poet. Hiding the paintings "behind curtains, in attics, above twenty-four flights of stairs" indicates that these thoughts and dreams are not shared with anyone who does not take great pains to get to know the poet. The discovery of love with another seems to rescue the poet, at least until the passion burns low the candles, leaving the lovers stuck in memories rather than clearing the way for real adventure.
9/10
This poem had me somewhat confused in that the setting jumps around quite rapidly: First the speaker is going to sea, then in a 24 storey house (I sense there was meaning here I missed) and then walking the streets. In a way this ties into the idea of being 'lost at sea' but I felt it was delivered in a little bit too much of a rushed way to make me really believe in the link. The poem does have some nice moments: the confessional line 'All I wanted was to hold you' is simple but powerful and effective, and I felt this poet incorporated the Spanish word more seamlessly into the poem. However it also lacked the sensual atmosphere for large parts and while it has potential, I was left a little disappointed by the end. 5/10
The obvious imagery in this poem describes the watercolor paintings of shipwreck--that is fading. I also think that the sea is another suitable and clever image in this poem especially being part of the last line, as it sums up the whole poem and effectively correlates to the opening line. 8/10
```````````````````````````````````
ROCKIN' TO THE 50'S
A spirited and fast paced sock hop. The action expresses joy of youth and the abandonment of caution that flows naturally from free spirits. The scene could be from a musical where impromptu dances occur in unlikely spots. The brick red Chevy brings Grease to mind.
7/10
The poet here managed to make the poem energy filled and alive, which replicates the feeling of the characters in the poem, and also ties in with the title. I can easily picture the scene, like something from the movie Grease: young, passionate and fun love. The Chevy came out of the blue as I imagined the pair to be dancing inside, and I wonder how the piano builds and builds. The wording of the poem is not exceptional in many cases: e.g. 'in perfect motion' isn't going to win any awards for most creative line-choice. But overall the tone and sounds in the poem are given priority by the poet and 'jive turkey' (somehow!) is used in an effective way. I could almost hear the music as a soundtrack as I read. Good effort 7/10
There is quite a bit of repetition in this poem though I don't necessarily see this as a bad thing, it's just the lack of utilization of punctuation (commas) is a bit distracting (for example: spinning spinning running), while the other lines are punctuated sparsely. Other than that, I really like the fast-paced tempo of this piece. 7/10
``````````````````````````````````````
STANDING OVATION
Some of the images are strikingly fresh ("clings ... like linen after a midsummer cita"). I enjoy the setting of a dance on the cobblestones; it reminds me of evening gatherings in typical Zócalos in Latin towns, taking one back several generations. I'm not sure what to make of caressing lost pennies or loving discounted thoughts.
6/10
This poem is full of interesting wording and imagery which helps makes it sensual success that it is. Descriptions such as 'tortiseshell eyes' and 'ciphered glances' tell us a lot about the relationship and the characters involved. I'm not sold on the inclusion of some Spanish words: They add somewhat to the Latin feel of the dance that is being portrayed but seem a little pointless otherwise when the English equivilant would do fine (I'd advise dropping them when posting when contest is over and bonus points don't count). The descriptions in some places don't make concrete sense, for example how can an echoing chant have a colour, or how can one swim through butterfly jasmine fields, but it works in this case because the words combine to make thought-provoking metaphors and create a strong, sensual atmosphere. I also like the clever reference to Round 2 at the end. 8/10
Analogies and metaphors are invaluable tools in poetry; however, they can also lead to misconceptions due to their inability to transcend the real. Being unique is a great thing, but in my opinion, putting out metaphors that are only clear to the author themselves, like I said, can lead to false impressions.
For example:
"field of butterfly jasmine;
a balm that spellbinds"
Field and balm don't seem to have a direct relationship with each other. 6/10
Poem #2 - Me Vuelves Loco
I love the opening stanza of this poem. The imagery of the couple's charm and elegance makes this piece -- a stimulating read. But the continuous use of latin words/phrases here, in my opinion, is a bit too much and unnecessary. 6/10
`````````````````````````````````````
EQUINOX
The immediate reaction is why were they enemies? How is a pomegranate diametrically opposed to a composer? Seems like the thought was to incorporate a fruit after the writing was done. Otherwise, the piece is lively and well done. The best lines, to me, are: "The crowd used their hands to paint the man and woman into each other's arms."
5/10
I quite enjoyed this poem. I think it is quite solid and consistant. I do think a new paragraph or punctuation could be used to seperate the man and woman and help create the distance/contrast between them. I was a little confused also about the 'crowd' - Where was this taking place? I got the impression of a crowd coming to see two people meet and dance for the first time, which is a little confusing. However these are quite minor details. I like how it ends 'until now' - This puts emphasis on the future, as if all has changed and their story together is another poem and is just beginning. Overall a decent effort. 6/10
Good title, very catchy and engaging. It gave me an instant urge to start reading right away, as well as offered me some idea or association to start with. However, the unavoidable problem with having a catchy title is when it offers somewhat more than what the poem delivers. I find the ending lines a bit overshadowed by the title's powerful impact. 8/10
`````````````````````````````````````
ME VUELVES LOCO
The story this poem tells is warm, even sensual. The Spanish phrases usually blend well (the with exception of "los callos eroticos" which I think does not mean what the poet thinks it means). The shift from describing the lover's a visual art to the actual dance is well done. On the other hand, the punctuation could be improved. A period after eroticos would be appropriate, for example.
7/10
Similarly to 'Standing Ovation,' but to an even greater extent, I think the Spanish words take from the poem somewhat and the poem itself would be better without them I think if written in the context of no bonus points. I don't understand Spanish so missing the of the end and of the end of some stanzas broke up the flow and broke my concentration somewhat, and draws my focus away from the message in the poem. Overall, I think the poem is quite solid, quite strong in places but doesn't stand out enough to score more highly. 6/10
I love the opening stanza of this poem. The imagery of the couple's charm and elegance makes this piece -- a stimulating read. But the continuous use of latin words/phrases here, in my opinion, is a bit too much and unnecessary. 6/10
```````````````````````````````````
BORDELLO ALLEY
A little snippet of a poem, like a photograph of the back alley of a jive hall. Well done, even if not much in depth.
6/10
I found this probably the most difficult poem to rate and judge, mainly due to it being so short. I think that the mention of Chicago is effective and a picture is painted of the streets as alive but somewhat seedy, and done so with few words. I think I miss the significance of the second stanza, and I'm not sure if 'hundred proof' works, but possibly that's due to my confusion more than anything. In ways it felt like the poem was only getting started. 'Jive turkey' may get 5 extra points but it doesn't do anything for the poem! Overall, I think I may rate this differently on each reading but I think a 5 is probably fair in my eyes, for a poem and poet that seem to have potential but keep the reader in the dark a little too much. 5/10
What I find interesting about this poem is its unique title, and how the Chicago Streets are being obliquely described. However, this poem appears to be a fragment, which is unfortunately too short for objectivity and developing characters. 6/10
`````````````````````````````````````
UNTITLED
Like the caffeinated rambling of a tired dancer after the halls are closed, sitting in a coffee shop, listening to beat jazz poetry. Love the unemployed cupid! So many disparate threads wrap around each other that the sheer lack of cohesiveness is itself entertaining.
5/10
The opening sentence caught my attention: it was crisp and profound but I was disappointed that it was followed by lazy or cliche words such as 'soul' and 'lust.' The ocassional rhyme is quite effective and in terms of flow and sound the poem does quite well, punctuation is well used. Overall though, some of the wording just lacked something special and parts such as 'But my cupid is unemployed,
he lost its 12 arrows by throwing them' and 'jive turkey' just sound a little off in a poem. There is a typo in the following line: 'I could have be doing this dance wrong.' - 'be' should be 'been.' Just a minor thing but overall the poem is a little rough around the edges and this is highlighted by the poets own confusion about what dance to write, as if he/she knows it isn't as successful as he/she would have liked. 4/10
This is such a simple poem drawn from common speech and conversational syntax that speaks so much of something so relatable for everyone. Moreover, I think "jive turkey" was well-placed. It's always a treat to read one which is humorous and at the same time, nicely executed such as this piece. 8/10
Thank you judges and everyone who entered! Round three is already up! :)
|