Everlasting
4 years ago
Shhh... |
Ben Pickard
replied to Everlasting
4 years ago
I have to be honest, the site has been quiet for years but it's worryingly so now. From poems posted, comments on poems, poems nominated and a willingness to judge, the site is in trouble at the moment. I know people are busy, but that doesn't change the facts. These halls are full of poetic ghosts at present... |
Poet on the Piano
replied to Everlasting
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Luce, you have such a creative mind, that's about all I can say on that ^_^ |
Everlasting
replied to Poet on the Piano
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Thanks MA, |
Saerelune
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I personally feel like the site has been like this for years, with members coming and going but always coming back again someday or just lingering (like me). It's never been extremely active the last ten years, but it was always a welcoming home nonetheless and we made it work with the few active members we did have. :) The last I remember the site being extremely vibrant was probably during Abby's (?) club-versus-club poetry marathon a few years back. |
Hellon
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I stopped posting on here after repeatedly being accused of bullying and trolling by members (one in particular) who I felt had only been on the site for a short time and , therefore, were unfamiliar with me on a personal level. Provoking people is something I did to get a reaction, something that stimulates the brain and, hence, leads to discussion. Sometimes these discussions became heated which, in my opinion is not a bad thing...certainly much better than what the threads have been seeing these past few months. |
silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Hellon, I think there are a lot of factors going into why the site has become so quiet, and political correctness might be one of those factors. What I think is people in general, including people on this site, don't know how to disagree well. I can't think of a single time someone was moderated on this site when they were arguing well. We have moderated when disagreements devolved to name-calling and ad hominem attacks, sure, but arguments should be able to become passionate without becoming disrespectful and off the rails. Unfortunately, respectful debates are especially tough on an online platform where tone can be misconstrued and interchanges are inherently impersonal. Also, many of us have years of history with each other and therefore we can tend to have emotional, reactionary responses that are disproportionate to the debate. |
Hellon
replied to silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Thanks for taking time to respond Jane. |
Michael
4 years ago
Hi all :) |
Poet on the Piano
4 years ago
So apparently, the first thread on the main forums was titled "Religion and America". Looking at the subjects for a lot of the topics over a decade ago, they were silly, fun and often asked the big questions that are controversial. The posts and replies read like very casual conversations, though a lot of posts seemed repetitive. With regards to controversy, that's great if it sparks debate and makes people feel passion and fire, but I'm always curious as to the intentions behind it. I don't come on here to talk about issues in the news, I see it enough and have it spiraling in my mind already. I come here for a break. To escape drama and cancel culture etc. I do think it'd be neat to bring the critique thread back, I think it got stuck and Luce was the last one to offer her poem, we could start that again. |
silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I have only read Hellon's post, so this is only responding to that: Hellon, what is your definition of political correctness? My definition is respectfulness and conscientiousness of the weight words carry and how terms can be used to oppress/mislead/fear-monger/stereotype, etc. I'm all for political correctness, and it seems to me that only the most privileged (white people) don't like it because it causes them the slightest inconvenience (e.g., oh now I have to remember to refer to someone as transgender, not transexual, woe is me!). |
Hellon
replied to silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
What I meant when I said that I was anti-political correct is this..in my opinion if a person is black or white we should be able to call them that, it's not disrespectful it's just a fact. On the other hand, if the words nigger or honky where used I would say that was definitely disrespectful and hurtful. Having said that I see no reason why we can no longer call the beloved toy a golly wog anymore, that's plain silly and something the 'do-gooders' of our society have caused. We have a beautiful tree here in Australia called Xanthorrhoea australis, yip. it's a mouthful but it was commonly known by ALL Australians as a black boy until some 'do-gooder' came along and said it's not politically correct to do so any more. |
silvershoes
replied to Hellon
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I think comparing the words n***** and honky is false equivalence. The "n" word is a term historically and presently used by whites to dehumanize blacks; to imply their inferiority and to “put them in their place," and the term is so painful that there have been movements in black culture to take ownership of the term and rebrand it to ameliorate that pain. The same truly cannot be said of honky, which tends to be used comically if at all. You can’t put white people in their place with a derogatory term when they own the place, so to speak. |
Hellon
replied to silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Your first sentence says it all for me..the n word? Really? it was a word used (wrongly I will be the first to admit) but to remove it from your vocabulary doesn't change anything. I know the reason why it was used and I did say I found it offensive. |
Everlasting
4 years ago
It’s nice to see arguments taking place in this thread. |
Hellon
replied to Everlasting
4 years ago
Thank you for starting the thread Luce...I'm just concerned over the well being of this site in general, that's all :) |
silvershoes
replied to Hellon
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Removing the n word from my vocabulary doesn't change anything? Huh. Try telling that to any black person. |
Everlasting
replied to silvershoes
4 years ago
“Hey Luce, such is the way of the internet that I can't tell if you were being serious or sarcastic. If you'd prefer us to move this convo to another thread, I'm happy to do that! Just say the word.“ |
silvershoes
replied to Everlasting
4 years ago
Oh yay! I'm so glad you're reading it. I thought it was fascinating! I bought 2 other Malcolm Gladwell books that I plan to read soon. |
Saerelune
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Hello! Just jumping in because I find your discussion intriguing. I'm not as nuanced and knowledgeable but as we are talking about what's considered racism or not I'd be interested in your views. (I am usually one of those ghosts that just reads your discussions because you're the earliest form of intelligent people I've been exposed to since my teenage years and I never really knew how to debate along.) |
silvershoes
replied to Saerelune
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
The short answer from a sociological point of view, and from my own point of view, is that yes there is absolutely racism targeting people who are all or part Asian. I’ve been focusing on black people because of the mention of a certain racial slur mentioned above, but much of my commentary applies to any person or persons of color. I want to give this topic the attention it deserves, but I’m headed out the door in a minute. My POV is that your fears of white people are a defense mechanism and a result of a lifetime of microaggressions, prejudice, and racism that you have experienced (and because “white” continues to be the socially dominant culture, globally) - not a result of some socioculturally learned sense of superiority like what many white people have. Even when Asian people are treated as a “token minority,” that is still racist. Benevolent racism is not much better than its counterpart. I would love to write more later. Someone assuming you carry Carona because you are Asian is wrong on so many levels. |
Saerelune
replied to silvershoes
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Thanks for your succinct answer Jane! That makes it feel a bit more digestible in my confused mind and makes a lot of sense. |
Hellon
4 years ago
I'd like to make one thing very clear here....I am not racist in any way. I'd like to highlight a part of Jane's post that turned the topic to black and white here... |
Saerelune
replied to Hellon
4 years ago
No worries Hellon, I didn't see this conversation as a sign of racism. Just a healthy discussion about nuances and boundaries. It is something I think about a lot because I am not white but also not black, that's why I jumped into the discussion. I know from the handful of talks we've had you've always been very interested and respectful of my cultural background. :) |
Saerelune
4 years ago
No worries Hellon, I understand both of your perspectives. |
nouriguess
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I just wanna say, that whatever happens, I would never, ever leave this site. Even if I am the only member left here. PnQ was never just a poetry website for me. The community here has taught me many things. Being fluent in English is one of them. Jane and Jordan, my Club members, have been pretty supportive throughout the years. Larry, MarryAnne, Hellon,..etc I can't count everyone, checking on me every now and then... that's so special. It's like we're a family, and I've never had this close connection with people I have never even met IRL. I love every part of PnQ. Some people here have known me ever since I was a silly teenager, and whether they know it or not, they helped me improve my personality and be more open-minded about many issues. |
nouriguess
4 years ago
Also, before Luce made this thread, I was going to start a thread about mental illness considering that I've been struggling. But I chickened out. Sorry. |
nouriguess
4 years ago
Did I scare everyone away with my sappy post? |
Star
replied to nouriguess
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I actually agree with you Noura I don't think I’ll ever permanently leave. I first joined in 2011 and since then P&Q has been a special place for me too :) |
Saerelune
replied to nouriguess
4 years ago
Same here noura. I built so many meaningful friendships here just that most of these people have left the site. I don't think I could ever delete my account here. I might come and go but pnq was such an important part of my teenage years, I regret it sooooo much that I deleted my account once before. Don't ever want to make that mistake again! |
nouriguess
replied to Saerelune
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I was very upset when you deleted your account. Don't do it again, please. |
nouriguess
replied to Star
4 years ago
What was your PnQ name before Star? I joined in 2009, maybe? Deleted my account. Don't regret it that much since most of my poetry was full of teenage angst and silly rhymes. Then rejoined after, like, a month, haha. |
Star
replied to nouriguess
4 years ago
I was wild flower then I think chamomile I left for two/three years, and here I am back again :) |
Saerelune
replied to nouriguess
4 years ago
Sorry about that. Really wasn't happy with my poetry back then and thought my existence as a poet didn't really matter, so I decided to leave.. but now that I think back I don't like that I did that because it's a part of my history however silly those poems were and if I still had them up there right now I'd see such a transformation. |
mossgirl19
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
Hello everyone...been absent here too most of the time. But still go back and enjoy reading. Yes, we love a little debate but we know we love each other too so let's just keep talking now so it won't be quiet here. |
Darren
4 years ago
Nice to read some healthy debating. |
Maher
4 years ago, updated 4 years ago
I've been on this site for years and didn't even know these threads existed! Here's to learning something new, eh? I feel like an Arab would, finding a free hookah & couch. I can say that because I'm Arab and have found a free hookah once. Blueberry-mint, I remember the flavour. Don't ask. Still holding out hope for the couch though. |
Hellon
replied to Maher
4 years ago
Maher...you made me laugh with your opening lines...finding a free hookah and a couch to enjoy it in haha!!! you know, I have a hookah in my house but, I've never actually tried it! I gave up smoking cigarettes seven years ago and, although I don't think there's any nicotine in the flavouring I'm afraid that going through the motions of inhaling would set me down the cigarette path again so...it's a beautiful thing to just look at for me :) |