Good Morning Everyone,
I hope you are all well and staying safe. First, I want to thank our judges for
their time and effort to make this weekly contest possible. Congratulations to the
front page Winners- Gracy Judith, Anthony Krieman and Daniel and those who
received Hm's. Well done everyone and here are the comments from the judges:
WINNERS://
Mute Moon by Gracy Judith (21 points)
Plans Change by Anthony Krieman (10 points)
Stem by Daniel (10 points)
COMMENTS://
Mute Moon by Gracy Judith (10 points)
“The imagery of this poem was simply breath-taking. I love how the
poem started with a moon that’s cut loose, which then ‘plunges’ into reality
(‘this verse’). It very much reminds me of the moon as a crescent-shaped boat,
as its anchor is cut loose. Not sure if it was intended, but I thought that this
particular word-choice was very effective. Gracy elegantly paints a certain
suspense with her diction: this “luring sphere” that’s quiet, yet wholly acknowledged
by the persona. This poem perfectly paints emotions through imagery, although
the meaning of it all seems a bit ambiguous… but I think that just adds
to its enchantment.”
````````````````````````````````````
Mute Moon by Gracy Judith (7 points)
Another one of those very talented new members, Gracy has my 7 points this
week with an image-filled little write about her wish for the moon to fall and
light her verse with silver shine. However, her "only companion" will not abandon
the sky and remains a fixed lure to this poet and her pen.
If I had a small gripe with this it would be the use of "luring sphere of gleam" –
the word "gleam" just doesn't sound quite right to me there, but it is personal
choice and it doesn't detract from this lovely early post from Gracy.
```````````````````````````````````
Mute Moon by Grace Judith (4 points)
This poem, though a quick read, was very poignant and well-written. The poet
personifies the poem in acknowledging that this is a poem - "I want to / cut loose
the moon / watch it plunge / into this verse". This works as a really strong
opening and great imagery of the moon hanging by a thread or hook being sent
plummeting to earth.
"My only companion / suspended / in the wide expanse / of grey" - The first two
lines are so beautifully structured, the loneliness of "my only companion" being
its own line, followed by just the word "suspended" - the word describing how it,
itself has been placed in the poem.
-------------------------------------------------
Plans Change by Anthony Krieman (10 points)
I have to say, this week has seen the site's joining with two or three outstanding
new members and Anthony is one of them. Sometimes, poets come along who
seem to just fit in very naturally and you struggle to imagine what the place was
like without them.
Anyway, in honesty, this was a selfish choice to some degree because - without
giving away too much - I read my own life's story here, with one or two variations.
We do not always end up doing exactly as we would have wished, but we often
look back and see that perhaps the path our life did take us on wasn't that different
after all. Fate is a funny thing indeed.
I loved this and as cliched as it may be, I related entirely. Well done and a really
warm welcome to the site, Anthony.
---------------------------------------------
Stem by Daniel (10 points)
This poem's utilization of imagery presents us with an extremely evocative piece.
The descriptions of a snake - both bloated and full, and of one slender and hungry
- paint a vivid scene for the reader to imagine.
"its rib cage yawning / open around a globular / mass of meat" - If anyone has seen,
in person or in photos, a snake eating, they can picture this very easily. The idea of a
rib cage yawning - it's just a mind-blowing description. Well done here.
With snakes being able to consume creatures/prey far larger than themselves, it
is a wonder at times how their bodies are able to digest their enormous meals
without splitting open. Daniel does a fantastic job describing this, as well as the
slithery nature of a starved snake - slender, limp. There's so much wonderful imagery
and the pacing itself snakes along at a gliding pace, much like the poem's subject
does over ground.
There are also many metaphors that can be drawn from this poem - some
religious, hearkening back to the biblical story of creation, or a metaphor for
class structure in society, a painting of the "haves" vs. the "have nots". It certainly
makes you think when reading it. Excellent piece!
HM’s://
An Untreated Case by nourayasmine (7 points)
I wrote her goodbye by Ben Pickard (4 points)
The Harbour at the End of the World by Shoreditchpoet Dennis (4 points)
In 13 by Rania Maollem (7 points)
COMMENTS//:
In 13 by Rania Moallem (7 points)
“Merely three lines, and it’s haunted my memory. That, to me, is a sign of an
excellent poem. Whilst the title is a bit unclear, I am assuming this has a
special symbolism attached to the writer. The poem itself was very articulate
and effective. The first line (embracing one’s soul, the deepest part of ourselves)
is intriguingly intimate. It made the next two lines punch even harder: the
stone-cold ‘ditching’, ‘bonelessness’ and an ‘empty pier’. The simple yet clever
combination of this all makes my stomach turn; it’s both brutal and beautiful.”
-----------------------------------
I wrote her goodbye by Ben Pickard (4 points)
“The first stanza felt achingly relatable… How all of us, as writers, conjure images
that become real as our similes and metaphors breathe life into them. The words
become a part of our veins, our body, and at one point we cannot contain them within
us anymore: our words will affect others. I get a sense of protection from the first few
lines; how the author might have tried to prevent this woman from drowning into
his words… but what’s done has been done. She’s a part of him, because she was a
part of his words. And as it all flowed into creation, it easily evaporated into musical
smoke… another art form; an eternal yet fleeting muse.
Although I am not sure if my interpretation is correct, I did enjoy the journey
that Ben took us on with his poem. From abstract metaphors to the tangible
smoke and aching lungs… The journey goes through high hopes and a sad goodbye,
but it’s this sense of loss that makes it so impactful. I almost wish to take the
smoke back, inhale it back in my lungs, just to keep the memory alive for a
little longer.”
------------------------------------------------
The Harbour at the End of the World by Shoreditchpoet Dennis (4 points)
A wonderfully accomplished poem, from its subtle rhyme and imagery, to its
Vibrancy and genuine feelings. A joy to read from start to finish and other very fine write
from a new member. Excellent stuff indeed.
-----------------------------------------------------
An Untreated Case by Nourayasmine (7 points)
The first line - like a letter - opened this poem very nicely. The poem reads very
much like a letter in its pacing and structure, also, which lends itself well to this
chosen style of introduction.
"When you ask me / about the nightmares / I make up less terrorizing ones." –
This is a powerful sentiment; trying to avoid re-visiting the darkness of our
thoughts/experiences by dampening their effects with imagined scenarios - still
terrifying, but less so than the actual events/thoughts.
"I did the math, and knew I was broken." - You can feel the pain of this line,
the hurt of feeling incomplete or shattered.
I thought the strong part of the piece was the string of different acronyms for
PTSD - this showed a strong creative approach to a difficult condition to deal with.
The ending as well hits you extremely hard when reading it, the poet's feeling that
they no longer exist.
Overall this poem was very strong and definitely deserving of nomination!
|