Judging poetry idea

Hello all,

I have been on this site for a little while know and I noticed that it often takes a long time for people to find poems and to judge them. Also I noticed that the feedback i get on the poetry is a bit like:
"Nice"
"Cool"
etc.

That is awsome you like my poems, but what is the reason why you give me 4 out of 5 or 5 out of 5 etc.

What my suggestion is..

I would like to have some more feedback on my poetry and also have some more people that want to have feedback.
If you think this is a good idea and you wish to join this, please put your name underneath here. I will add you to my favourites and I will try to comment and judge the poems you make every week. In return I would like people to do the same for me. Some nice feedback like: "I liked this this and this, I myself should improve this this and this" is good feedback! :)

So if you like the idea please leave your name here and I will add you to favourites :)

I hope a lot of people will react on this

~Darkbreath~

i totally agree -lisa1983

i extremely agree with you i am --jessica.xx
as you can tell my names jessica but anyways. ill add you to my favourites too.

I'd help but more to give honest comments to somebody who wants them.

I am getting very good reactions from people on this! :) good job all..

I hope more will tag along in this. I will keep bumping this topic some times..

please also accept each other in favourites :)

I always give critism when i comment people. That's the whole point in commenting them. but when people leave me a "Nice poem, comment mine?" I give them a one liner back.
I don't give my time to people who don't give it back =)
Gem x

i agree. i always write what i like about peoples poems and not the bad stuff so i'll start doing that. and i added you bye x

Hey guys..

Thanks again for the reactions! keep it going. I added all the people that reacted on this post to my favourites and I will be reading posts of you regulary. I need to share for a moment how ever, that though of a recent thing in my life I might not react really quick.. If you want to know, just keep checking my poetry

The second thing i want to ask if someone could judge my poem in the morning. It is one of the poems i made that is a very personal and represents a part of my life I closed.

Cheers

Darkbreath

If you give good, worthy comments, I'd love to hear your comments on my poetry.
However, you don't need to add me to your favorites unless you think you want to. I leave that up to you.
And, I will comment back in return. But, I give honest critism and always have.
Enjoy.x

xTheEcstasyOfSuicidex