What do I do?

I really really like this person and I have liked this person for a while...and then this other person shows up..and I'm starting to have feelings for him...do I stick with the person I've liked, even thought there may or may not be a chance with the two of us..or do you get over the person and stick to the new person??

I think you should see how things go with the first person especcially if he likes you too 'cause it's better to know if you could have a chance with him than not knowing. And if things don't work out than you can go with the new person.

But I can also argue with what I just said and say that you can't want to be with the first guy if you have feelings for the new guy 'cause the relationship will be unstable.

So what I'm basically saying is that I can't really make this choice for you but just give you possibilities of what the outcome could be with the choice you make.

I hope I helped and I hope you make the right choice.

You need to sit down and figure out who you like more. It's that easy. Then when you have made your decision just be friends with the guy that you didn't pick.

Okay,
it's normal to go through this phase. Liking more than one guy at a time. That's why sometimes it's best to just date before getting involved in a relationship. Try hanging out with them both individually and decide which one you like more. Then the next step (if you havn't done this already) would be to tell that guy you like him..and see where things go from there.